How to tell if your SEO company is working: a 15 minute check
Check the work yourself: non-branded clicks in Search Console, Business Profile calls, real site changes, rankings and links, plus the questions to ask before you renew.
Thinking of cancelling your SEO retainer? What keeps working after you stop, what fades and why, a routine you can run yourself, and when cancelling makes sense.
What happens if you stop SEO? Usually nothing on the day you cancel. Your pages stay in Google, links from real websites keep counting and your reviews stay on your Business Profile. What changes is the direction. Competitors keep working, links the agency rents can disappear, your pages and profile go stale, and small problems pile up with nobody watching.
How much that costs you depends on what the retainer paid for. Real work on a site you own keeps paying you back, and a short routine you can run yourself protects a lot of it. Rented links, or a website the agency owns, can be gone the week you cancel.
When we audit a site after an SEO contract ends, we sort what the owner paid for into 2 piles: what they own, and what needed someone working on it every month.
| What you paid for | After you stop | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Pages on your own site | Stay indexed and keep ranking while they stay useful | You own them |
| Links from real local sites | Stay | They last as long as the linking page |
| Google reviews | Stay and keep counting | They sit on your profile |
| Links the agency rents or controls | Can vanish | They stop when the payments stop |
| Your spot against competitors | Slips if they keep working | Rankings are relative |
| Business Profile details | Drift if nobody checks | Google and the public can change them |
| Plugins, forms, speed | Wear down | Nobody is updating or testing |
| A site, domain or tracking numbers the agency owns | Can switch off the day you cancel | Your contract decides |
Service pages, location pages and articles live on your website, so they stay in Google's index as long as the site is up. A good page about drain cleaning in your city doesn't expire. Google's freshness systems are designed to show fresher content "for queries where it would be expected", like news about an earthquake that just happened. Most searches for a local service are not that kind of query.
What does age is the detail: a service you dropped, a team member who left, old photos, an expired offer. Google's SEO Starter Guide lists up to date content as a sign of a useful page and suggests you check older content and update it as needed.
A link from a supplier's dealer page, a trade association or a local news story stays as long as that page stays up. Google's local ranking help says prominence is partly based on "how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have."
To see what you have, open the Links report in Search Console. Google's site move guide sends owners to Search Console to find the links to their site and says to save a list of the sites linking to them. Save yours before you cancel.
Reviews belong to your Business Profile, not to the agency, and they stay when you cancel. Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking. The profile stays yours too, as long as you are its primary owner. Check in Business Profile settings, under People and access. Managers can't add or remove users, so if the agency is the primary owner and you are only a manager, fix that before you give notice.
Redirects, a faster theme and fixed indexing errors stay fixed unless someone changes the site.
Send your website and we will record a free 2 minute video on what is holding your rankings back, with the 3 fixes we would make first.
Not overnight, and not because Google notices you stopped. They drop for 4 reasons.
Some retainers pay for links month by month, on blogs the agency controls or through a vendor. When the payments stop, those links can come down. Buying links for ranking purposes breaks Google's spam policies unless the links are marked sponsored or nofollow. In its December 2022 link spam update, Google said SpamBrain can detect both sites buying links and sites used to pass them, and that rankings may change as those links are neutralized. Before you cancel, ask for a list of every link built for you. If most sit on sites the agency runs, expect those to go.
Rankings are relative. Google's guide to debugging drops in search traffic reminds site owners that "positions aren't static or fixed in place." If the 2 roofers above you keep adding project pages and reviews while you stand still, the gap grows. The slide is slow, so it is easy to miss until the phone gets quieter.
Google can update your profile from user reports and other sources. If you don't respond to a suggested edit within 4 days, Google may publish it when other public information, such as your website, supports it (Google Business Profile Help). Posts older than 6 months are archived unless you set a date range, so a busy profile looks quiet 6 months after the posting stops. Our guide on why Google keeps changing your business hours shows how to catch those edits.
Nobody updates plugins, tests the contact form or notices a page that broke. WordPress's own hardening guide says older versions "are not maintained with security updates" and tells you to keep plugins updated. Google's traffic drop guide lists security issues such as malware among the causes of lost search traffic.
What happens when you stop SEO services depends most on who owns what. Before you give notice, confirm each of these is in your name, under your login:
Watch tracking numbers. If the numbers on your profile and listings belong to the agency and get switched off, those calls stop. Put your real number back first. Our guide on how to fire your marketing agency covers the full exit in order.
Partly. The big pieces are mostly one time: a clear site structure, a page for each main service and area, a complete Business Profile with the right categories, and fixed technical errors. Done well, they keep working without a monthly invoice.
The upkeep is not one time, but it is small: reviews, profile posts, fresh photos and occasional page updates. Google's starter guide says some changes take effect in a few hours and others take several months, so steady small work beats a big push followed by nothing.
If you cancel, this is the routine we would hand an owner or office manager.
Ask everyone, not only happy customers, and never offer a discount or freebie for a review. Our guide to getting more Google reviews shows where to find the link and covers Google's rules and the wording.
Don't just change the date on a page. Google's guidance on helpful content asks whether you are "changing the date of pages to make them seem fresh when the content has not substantially changed."
Cancelling is a normal business decision. Use this table to make it.
| Cancel or switch if | Keep paying if |
|---|---|
| You can't get a plain list of what was done each month | You can see real work: new pages, fixes, profile updates |
| The agency won't give you owner access to your own accounts | You own every account and they work inside it |
| They promise a #1 ranking or guaranteed results | They report calls, leads and non-branded clicks, not just rankings |
| Most links come from sites they control | You are opening a new area or adding a service |
| Several months of work and your calls haven't moved | Competitors in your Maps results are clearly investing |
| You will run the routine yourself | Nobody on your team will run it |
2 of those red flags come straight from Google. Its page Do you need an SEO? says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" and warns about companies that are secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do. Not sure your provider is doing anything? Run the checks in how to tell if your SEO company is working first.
There is a middle option too: drop to a smaller plan, or pay for a one time audit, then run the routine yourself. DIY stops making sense when calls or traffic fall sharply and you can't explain why. A professional would check Search Console for manual actions, security issues and indexing errors, and compare the Links report with the list you saved. That is the first thing our local SEO team looks at when an owner brings us a site after an agency.
Before you cancel, get owner access to your domain, website, Business Profile and Search Console, and export the reports and link list. Next, note this month's profile calls and Search Console clicks as a baseline. Then start the routine and compare each month with the same month last year.
If you want a second opinion first, send us your site and we'll record a free 2 minute video audit showing the 3 fixes we'd make first, whether you keep your current SEO provider or not.
There is no set timeline, and Google doesn't penalize you for stopping. Rankings move when something changes: rented links come down, competitors add pages and reviews, or your site and profile go out of date. That can take weeks or many months. Compare Search Console clicks and Business Profile calls with the same period last year, so you see a slide early.
No. Reviews are attached to your Business Profile, not to the agency's account, so they stay when you cancel. The real risk is losing control of the profile. Open Business Profile settings, then People and access, and make sure you are the primary owner, not a manager. Managers can't add or remove users, so an agency that is the only owner controls the profile.
You can pause the payments, but try not to pause the work. Google says some changes take a few hours to show in search and others take several months, so pages, photos and reviews added in the slow months are what show up when demand returns. If you pause, keep the weekly review requests and the monthly profile check going yourself.
Yes, for most of the upkeep a local business needs: asking for reviews, posting on your Business Profile, keeping your details right, updating your main pages and keeping WordPress patched. It takes a few minutes a week, under an hour a month and a longer session each quarter. Bring in help for a site rebuild, a new domain, a sudden traffic drop or a new location.
The 3 fixes we'd make first on your site, within 1 business day.