Skip to content

How to tell if your SEO company is working: a 15 minute check

Check the work yourself: non-branded clicks in Search Console, Business Profile calls, real site changes, rankings and links, plus the questions to ask before you renew.

Here is how to tell if your SEO company is working: check the numbers they can't dress up. In Google Search Console, compare clicks from searches that don't include your business name with the same months last year. In your Business Profile, compare calls and direction requests. Then confirm the pages they say they improved actually changed.

Ranking screenshots and impression charts are easy to make look good. Non-branded clicks, profile calls and dated page changes are not. You can check all of them in about 15 minutes. All you need from the agency is access.

Start with the cost. Add up what you've paid in the last 6 months. Then ask whoever answers the phone how many new customers found you by searching Google for the service, not your name. Keep both numbers in front of you.

5 minute check: in Search Console, open Performance, click the filter bar, choose Query, then Non-branded. Set the date filter to compare the last 3 months year over year. If clicks are flat or down after 6 months of paid work, that is your first question for the agency.

How to tell if your SEO company is working: the 15 minute check

You need 3 logins: Search Console, your Google Business Profile and your website's admin. If you don't have the first one, that is a finding on its own.

CheckWhereGood sign
Non-branded clicksSearch Console, PerformanceUp against the same months last year
Calls and directionsBusiness Profile, PerformanceUp, or steady through a slow season
Site changesYour site's revision historyDated changes to service and city pages
RankingsA private window, plus a grid checkYour money keywords, across your service area
LinksSearch Console, LinksReal sites that match their report

Check Search Console clicks over 3, 6 and 16 months

This is the main way to check if SEO is working. Search Console shows how often your site appeared in Google and how often people clicked. Clicks matter most.

Compare the right periods

  1. Open Search Console, then Performance, then Search results.
  2. Click the date filter at the top of the chart, choose Compare, and pick Compare last 3 months to previous period. This shows the recent direction.
  3. Switch to Compare last 3 months year over year. Google's guide to debugging search traffic drops suggests both comparisons, plus a 16 month view to spot seasonal patterns.
  4. Set the date filter to Last 6 months, then Last 16 months. Find the month the agency started on the chart and look at the line after it.

Separate branded from non-branded searches

Branded searches include your business name. Those people already know you and would find you anyway. SEO work should show up mainly in non-branded searches, like "water heater repair near me".

Google's guide to common Performance report tasks says to click the filter bar, select the Query filter and choose Branded or Non-branded. The filter has data from March 11, 2025, and it isn't available for sub-properties or sites with a low number of impressions.

If you don't see it, use the advanced filters instead: click + Add filter, choose Queries, then Custom (regex), switch to Doesn't match regex and type your business name.

See which queries and pages moved

With a comparison on, the table adds a Difference column. Sort the Queries tab by it to see what rose and what fell, then do the same on the Pages tab. You want gains on the service pages and city pages the agency says it worked on. Google's Performance report guide notes that news events or improvements to a competing site can also move your numbers, so check that gains line up in timing with the changes.

Competitors showing up above you on Google?

Send your website and we will record a free 2 minute video on what is holding your rankings back, with the 3 fixes we would make first.

Get my free video audit

Check Business Profile calls and direction requests

If your SEO company manages your Business Profile, its numbers belong in this check. Google's steps to see Business Profile performance:

  1. Go to your Business Profile on Google Search and click Performance. In the Google Maps app, tap Business at the bottom right, then See more next to Performance.
  2. Select a time period at the top and click Apply.
  3. Write down calls, directions and website clicks, then repeat for the same months last year.

Calls counts clicks on the call button on your profile, not answered calls. Directions is how many people asked for directions. Searches shows the terms people used to find you, updated at the start of each month.

If almost every search term is your business name, the profile isn't winning new customers. If calls dropped suddenly, our guide on why a Google Business Profile ranking dropped walks through the causes.

Check whether anything on your site actually changed

SEO work leaves fingerprints: new pages, rewritten service pages, fixed titles. Google's guide Do you need an SEO? says an SEO with access to your server should be willing to explain all the changes they are making to your site.

On WordPress

WordPress keeps a record of each saved update to a page. To view revisions:

  1. Open a page the agency says it improved, in the editor.
  2. Open the Settings sidebar and select the Page tab.
  3. Click the number next to Revisions.
  4. Move through the saved versions and see what was added or removed, and whether any version is newer than the month they started.

Some sites keep only a few revisions, or none, so an empty history is a question to ask, not proof. Check your homepage, top service page and main city page.

On other platforms

Ask for a dated list of every URL they published or changed in the last 90 days, then open each one. 4 short blog posts a month on topics your customers never search for is activity, not progress.

Rank checks on your money keywords

Pick 3 searches that bring paying work: the service plus your city, such as "roof repair Tulsa" or "emergency plumber Mesa". Google explains that it uses your location, past Search history and Search settings to choose results, and a page you've visited several times can move to the top for you.

  1. Open a private window, not signed in to Google.
  2. Search each keyword. Note where your site appears in the regular results and whether you show in the map results.
  3. Repeat on your phone from a job site across town.

A private window removes your history, not your location. That matters most for map results, because Google's local ranking factors are mainly relevance, distance and prominence. You can be in the top 3 near the office and missing 5 miles away. A geogrid tool checks one keyword from a grid of points across your service area. If your agency sends these, ask for the same keywords and grid every month.

In Search Console, open Links and look at Top linking sites under External links. Google says the Links report isn't a full list of every link to your site, so one missing link proves nothing. Many missing links is a question.

  • Open 5 links from their report at random. Does the page load, and does it link to your site?
  • Is the site real and related to you, like a local news site, trade association or supplier? Or is it a directory or bookmark site nobody reads?

Google's spam policies list paying for links, excessive link exchanges, links made with automated programs, low-quality directory or bookmark links and forum comments with optimized links as link spam. Sites that break those policies may rank lower or not appear at all. Google's hiring guide adds that you should never have to link to an SEO.

Signs your SEO company is not doing anything

Give new work time: Google's SEO Starter Guide says some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months. One sign alone proves little. 2 or 3 together, after 6 months of paid work, is when you ask hard questions.

What you seeWhat it often meansWhat to ask for
Clicks grew only on branded searchesGrowth from your reputation or ads, not SEONon-branded queries that gained clicks
Impressions up, clicks and calls flatShowing for more searches, too low to get clicksPages that now get clicks and didn't before
No page changes in 90 daysLittle or no work on the siteA dated list of changed URLs
Links you can't find, or directory linksPadding, or link spam riskLive URLs for every link
Rankings only in their screenshotsOne location, or a personalized searchKeyword, location and method used
No access to your own Search ConsoleYou can't check anythingOwner access, in writing

How to know if your SEO is good: read the report

A useful monthly report shows:

  • Calls and form leads from organic search and the Business Profile, and how they were counted.
  • Non-branded clicks compared with the same months last year.
  • Every URL published or changed, with dates.
  • Links built, with live URLs.
  • Rank checks with the keyword, location and method stated.

Impressions, a count of "keywords ranked" and a traffic graph with no comparison show the agency was busy, not that the work paid off.

What to ask your SEO company before you renew

Google's own list of questions to ask an SEO includes "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure your success?" and whether they will share all the changes they make to your site. Here is an email you can send:

  1. Which pages did you publish or change in the last 90 days? Please send the URLs and dates.
  2. Which non-branded searches brought more clicks this quarter than the same quarter last year?
  3. How many calls and form leads came from organic search and our Business Profile, and how do you count them?
  4. Which links did you build? Please send the live URLs.
  5. What results did you expect by now, and what will you change next quarter?
  6. Please give me owner access to our Search Console property.

A provider doing the work answers within a few days, with links. If your SEO company is not getting results and replies with vague answers, a sudden promise of first place or no access to your own accounts, plan your exit. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and our post on SEO scam emails covers the other pitches to ignore. Before you give notice, read how to fire your marketing agency so you secure every login first, and what happens if you stop SEO so you know what stays.

If the numbers are flat and you can't tell whether the cause is the agency, your website or your market, a second opinion helps. These are the checks we run before we touch anything in a local SEO project.

What to do next

Today, run the non-branded clicks comparison in Search Console and the calls check in your Business Profile. This week, look at the revision history of your 3 most important pages and send the agency the 6 questions above. At renewal, decide based on their answers and the numbers, not on the report's charts. That is how to tell if your SEO company is working without waiting for their next report.

Want a second opinion first? Send us your site and we'll record a free 2 minute video audit showing the 3 fixes we'd make first.

Common questions

How long should SEO take to show results?

There is no fixed timeline. Google's SEO Starter Guide says some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months, and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging whether work helped. The work itself should be visible from the first month: changed pages, fixed problems, dated reports. If you see no work after 3 months, ask why before you worry about rankings.

Can an SEO company guarantee first page rankings?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and that if an SEO promises their changes will put you in first place, you should find someone else. For map results, Google also says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. A guarantee is a sales tactic, not a plan.

Should I have my own access to Search Console?

Yes. Search Console is where Google reports your clicks, queries and links, so it is the main way to check your SEO company's work. Ask to be an owner of your site's property, not just a user the agency added. If they won't give you owner access, treat that as a warning sign.

Why is my SEO traffic down if the agency says rankings are up?

Several things can be true at once. Rankings may be up for searches few people make, or only from one location. Traffic may be down because of your busy and slow seasons. Compare the last 3 months year over year in Search Console, filtered to non-branded queries. If that is down too, ask the agency which pages lost clicks and why.

Get your free video audit

The 3 fixes we'd make first on your site, within 1 business day.

Send my website
Free video auditWhatsApp