Should I switch from WooCommerce to Shopify? 3-year costs, 7 signs
A straight answer for small store owners: what WooCommerce and Shopify really cost over 3 years, 7 signs it's time to move, when to stay, and what the move involves.
When Google traffic falls after a move to Shopify, old URLs that now return 404 are the first thing to check. Here is how to find them, redirect them in bulk and fix what else broke.
If traffic dropped after migrating to Shopify, the most likely cause is that your old page addresses now return 404 errors. Shopify uses fixed paths such as /products/ and /collections/, so most old product, category and blog URLs changed. Find those old URLs, redirect each one to its closest new page, then restore what didn't move.
Some dip is normal. Google's site move guide says a medium-sized site can take a few weeks or more before the new URLs replace the old ones in search. A drop that keeps growing, or a long list of 404 errors in Search Console, means something broke.
This guide covers recovery first, then how to migrate WooCommerce to Shopify without losing SEO if your move is still ahead.
Google ranks your store page by page, so an address that stops working loses its rankings. After a move, these are the causes we check first:
If your analytics tag never made it onto the new theme, sessions can fall to near zero while Google still sends visitors. Search Console counts clicks in Google's own results, so it doesn't depend on your tags. If Search Console clicks held steady, fix the tracking, not the SEO. If your store has vanished from Google entirely, read why your Shopify store isn't showing up on Google.
After a move the old site is often gone, so use these sources in this order:
Put everything in one spreadsheet, remove duplicates, keep only the path (such as /product/blue-hoodie/) and sort by clicks, so the pages that earned money come first.
Send your website and we will record a free 2 minute video on what is holding your rankings back, with the 3 fixes we would make first.
Shopify's URL redirects are 301 redirects, the permanent type Google's site move guide recommends. You can add them one at a time or import hundreds at once by CSV.
With WooCommerce's standard permalink settings, products sit under /product/, and the default category and tag bases are /product-category/ and /product-tag/. They usually map like this:
| Old URL (example) | New Shopify URL |
|---|---|
| /product/blue-hoodie/ | /products/blue-hoodie |
| /product-category/hoodies/ | /collections/hoodies |
| /product-tag/winter/ | The closest collection |
| /how-to-wash-a-hoodie/ | /blogs/news/how-to-wash-a-hoodie |
| /size-guide/ | /pages/size-guide |
Shopify's product CSV has no column for WooCommerce categories, so create each collection before you point a redirect at it.
Redirect from and Redirect to, the headers in Shopify's sample template.Blog posts are the easiest thing to leave behind, because WooCommerce exports don't include them. Every Shopify store has a default blog called News, so posts land under /blogs/news/ unless you create another blog. To restore a lost post:
Do the same for size guides, FAQ pages and buying guides, which now live under /pages/. If you later change the web address of a page or blog inside Shopify, it preselects a Create a URL redirect option. Leave it on.
Shopify's WooCommerce guide tells you to review each product's meta description after import, so compare your top 20 pages from Step 1 with their Wayback Machine copies.
Shopify's SEO help suggests titles of up to 60 characters and about 160 for descriptions. For image alt text, open the product, click the image, then Edit alt text.
Google's site move guide says each new URL should have a canonical tag pointing to itself. Paste your top pages into the URL Inspection tool: the User-declared canonical and Google-selected canonical should both be the new Shopify URL. If either shows an old address, look for a theme edit or app that hard-coded it.
Google's guide also says to update internal links to the new URLs. Search menus, footers, product descriptions and imported posts for old /product/ and /product-category/ links, and swap in the new ones.
Shopify generates your sitemap automatically at yourdomain.com/sitemap.xml. In Search Console, open Sitemaps, enter sitemap.xml and click Submit. Shopify notes that Google can't read the sitemap while the store is in private mode. Crawling takes time, and Google doesn't guarantee how long.
Google says a medium-sized site can take a few weeks or more for the new URLs to replace the old ones, and larger sites take longer. When you click Validate fix in the Page indexing report, validation typically takes up to about 2 weeks. Keep your redirects as long as possible, Google says, and generally at least 1 year.
| Check weekly | Where | What good looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 404 errors | Page indexing, Not found (404) | Old URLs move to Page with redirect |
| Clicks by page | Performance, Pages tab | New URLs gain clicks as old ones fade |
| Sitemap | Sitemaps report | Status shows Success |
If the 404 list is clean, the redirects test fine and clicks still aren't returning after several weeks, the cause is deeper, such as cut content or pages Google treats as duplicates. That is when a side-by-side crawl of the old and new store pays for itself.
If you haven't moved yet, most of this is avoidable. Shopify's WooCommerce guide recommends setting up redirects before you transfer your domain. Your Shopify SEO migration checklist:
Our website redesign SEO checklist covers the same logic for any rebuild. If you're still deciding, read should you switch from WooCommerce to Shopify first. A full URL map and redirect test is part of how we approach Shopify store development.
If traffic dropped after migrating to Shopify, run the 5 minute check first to confirm the move caused it. Then build your list of old URLs and import the redirects by CSV, highest-traffic pages first. After that, restore lost posts, titles and descriptions, and watch Search Console weekly for a month.
If you want a second pair of eyes on the new store, send it to us and we'll record a free 2 minute video audit showing the 3 fixes we'd make first.
Some movement is normal. Google says to expect temporary ranking changes during any site move, and that a medium-sized site can take a few weeks or more before the new URLs replace the old ones. A drop that keeps growing, or a long list of 404 errors in Search Console, is not normal. It usually means old URLs were never redirected to their new Shopify pages.
Not the URLs from your old platform. Shopify's migration guide has you create those redirects yourself, one at a time or by CSV import under Content, Menus, URL redirects. Shopify does preselect a Create a URL redirect option when you change the web address of a page or blog. Redirects only work from broken URLs, so a page that still loads at the old path blocks them.
No. Shopify treats /products and /collections as fixed paths, pages sit under /pages/ and blog posts under /blogs/ plus the blog's name. You can only change the handle at the end of each URL. That's why a move from WooCommerce, which typically uses /product/ and /product-category/, needs a redirect for every old product and category URL.
Google says to keep redirects for as long as possible, and generally at least 1 year. On Shopify there's little reason to remove them, since a store can hold up to 100,000 redirects, or 20 million on Shopify Plus. Removing one also doesn't take effect for everyone right away, because browsers and search engines cache 301 redirects.
No. Google's site move guidance warns against redirecting many old URLs to an irrelevant page, such as the home page. Send each old URL to its closest match: the same product, the matching collection or the recreated blog post. If a product is gone for good and nothing similar exists, its parent collection is still a better landing spot than the home page.
The 3 fixes we'd make first on your site, within 1 business day.