Traffic dropped after migrating to Shopify? How to get it back
When Google traffic falls after a move to Shopify, old URLs that now return 404 are the first thing to check. Here is how to find them, redirect them in bulk and fix what else broke.
A straight answer for small store owners: what WooCommerce and Shopify really cost over 3 years, 7 signs it's time to move, when to stay, and what the move involves.
Should I switch from WooCommerce to Shopify? Switch if keeping WooCommerce running now costs you more in hosting, plugin renewals and developer hours than a Shopify plan and its apps would, or if updates keep breaking your store. Stay if your store is stable, your traffic comes from WordPress content, or your products need more than 3 options.
The monthly price is the wrong place to start. WooCommerce is free to install and every Shopify plan has a clear monthly price, but neither is what you will actually pay. What decides it is 3 years of hosting, extensions, payment fees and the hours someone spends keeping the store working.
WooCommerce gives you full control and full responsibility. Shopify takes most of the technical work off your plate for a monthly fee, and you work inside its rules.
Switch to Shopify if:
Stay on WooCommerce if the store runs well and costs less, or if content, complex products or custom code tie you to it (more below).
Compare 36 months, not 1, because renewals, fixes, apps and fees all add up over time. WooCommerce's own pricing page calls WooCommerce free and open source, then puts hosting at $25 to $350 a month for most stores and paid extensions at $29 to $299 a year each. Shopify's pricing page lists Basic at $25 a month billed monthly or $19 a month billed yearly, Grow at $65 or $49, and Advanced at $399 or $299, with hosting included. New Shopify stores currently get a 3 day free trial, then $1 a month for 3 months.
| Cost line | WooCommerce, 3 years | Shopify, 3 years |
|---|---|---|
| Platform | $0, the core plugin is free | Basic: $684 billed yearly or $900 billed monthly. Grow: $1,764 or $2,340 |
| Hosting | $900 to $12,600 at $25 to $350 a month | Included in the plan |
| Paid extensions or apps | $87 to $897 for each extension | Depends on the apps, billed separately |
| Outside payment provider | Only your processor's fees | Your processor's fees plus 2% on Basic |
| Upkeep | Developer hours for updates, PHP upgrades and fixes | Fewer technical hours, but theme and app changes still take time |
| The move itself | $0 | Free import app, third-party apps for orders and reviews, plus redirect and testing time |
Card fees are close to a tie for a US store. WooPayments charges 2.9% + $0.30 per domestic card, plus 1.5% for international cards and 1% for currency conversion, with no monthly fee for online payments. Shopify's comparison page lists Shopify Payments from 2.9% + $0.30 on Basic, and a 2% fee on Basic when you use a third-party provider instead.
That 2% is where a switch can quietly get expensive. Shopify's help page on third-party transaction fees says the rate depends on your plan, and that orders paid through Shopify Payments, Shop Pay, Shop Pay Installments or manual methods don't carry it. PayPal is also exempt when Shopify Payments is your main provider.
Check staff logins too. Shopify's pricing page shows no additional staff accounts on Basic, 5 on Grow and 15 on Advanced. If anyone else needs a login, compare against Grow, not Basic.
Pull a year of invoices from whoever maintains the site and split them into upkeep (updates, PHP upgrades, fixing what broke) and improvements. Only upkeep goes in the comparison, because you would still pay for improvements on Shopify. If you do the work yourself, count your own hours.
As a reference, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the median wage for web developers and digital designers at $47.85 an hour in May 2025. At that rate, 3 hours of upkeep a month for 3 years comes to about $5,170, before any emergency fix.
Shopify's comparison page says WooCommerce operating costs are 41% higher on average. Its TCO page says that research was commissioned by Shopify from a consulting firm it doesn't name, and surveyed 250 enterprises in the US and Canada with revenue of $10 million or more, between December 2023 and January 2024. That says little about a small store. Trust your own invoices over any vendor's average, including migration app makers who earn money when you move.
Send your store and we will record a free 2 minute video showing the 3 fixes we would make first to lift sales.
One of these on its own is a fixable problem. When 3 or 4 describe your store, the platform is probably costing you more than it should.
Shopify isn't automatically the better choice. Staying makes sense when:
If the numbers and the signs point to Shopify, plan the move before you pay for anything. Shopify's WooCommerce migration guide covers the mechanics. In short:
Redirects carry most of the search risk. Our guide to fixing a traffic drop after migrating to Shopify shows how to find every old URL and redirect it in bulk. Read it before launch.
A small catalog of simple products is a fair do-it-yourself move. With custom features, years of orders or thousands of URLs that get search traffic, have someone experienced map it out. That is the kind of work our Shopify store development team takes on.
Not sure whether to switch, or just fix a few parts of the store you have? Send us your URL and we'll record a free 2 minute video audit showing the 3 fixes we'd make first.
Neither is better for every store. Shopify suits owners who want hosting, security and updates handled for a monthly fee, and who can work within Shopify's apps and fixed URL paths. WooCommerce suits owners with a reliable developer, a lot of WordPress content, or products that need more than 3 options. Compare 3 years of your real costs, not the headline prices.
Sometimes. WooCommerce is free, but its own pricing page puts hosting at $25 to $350 a month and extensions at $29 to $299 a year each, plus developer time. Shopify's Basic plan is $19 a month billed yearly with hosting included, but apps cost extra and Basic adds a 2% fee if you use an outside payment provider. Add up 36 months of your own costs to know.
No. Shopify's WooCommerce migration guide says customer passwords can't be migrated. Imported customers who use Shopify's customer accounts sign in with a one-time verification code, so they don't need a new password. On legacy customer accounts, they have to create a new one. Tell your repeat buyers before launch so nobody is surprised.
It can, because your URLs change. Shopify uses its own paths, such as /products and /collections, so old WooCommerce links break unless you redirect them. Create a redirect for every old URL that gets traffic or links, in Content, then Menus, then View URL Redirects, or import a CSV. Standard plans allow up to 100,000 redirects. Test your most visited pages first after launch.
The 3 fixes we'd make first on your site, within 1 business day.